Coal phase-out must overcome “us and them” mentality

  Last updated July 29, 2020 at 11:00 am


“Success requires looking after the interests of workers, local communities as well as the energy industry, but not forgetting the interests of energy users and taxpayers.”

coal power station

Bayswater Power Station in the Hunter Valley. Credit: zetter/Getty Images

Why This Matters: Let’s be prepared for change.

Coal will need to be phased out of the world’s economy to meet the climate change challenge, but this can work properly only if social objectives and local stakeholders are involved in the process.

That’s the argument from an international group of researchers in a paper published in the journal Nature Climate Change

A coal phase-out will require a process of ‘just transition’ that focuses on the rights and livelihoods of workers and agreed roadmaps, appropriate policy instruments, and effective ways to include workers, regions and industry in the process, the group say.

Also: Australia’s devotion to coal has come at a huge cost. The government needs to change course, urgently

They argue that coal phase-out must be seen as fair and take account of political realities, which may mean effectively compensating affected groups and counterbalancing powerful vested interests.

The study was led by researchers at the Mercator Institute in Berlin and co-authored by academics and researchers from Australia, the UK, Germany, India and the United States. Professor Frank Jotzo from The Australian National University (ANU) was part of the team.

The transition away from coal can be difficult

“In Australia, coal use is invariably on the way out, as renewable energy is now the cheaper way of producing electricity from new plants, and Australia’s coal power plant fleet is relatively old. Coal is also being phased down quite rapidly in much of Europe and North America,” says Jotzo.

“The closure of Hazelwood and the controversies over the planned closure of the Liddell coal plant show that this transition can be difficult.

“The lesson from the experiences in other countries is that closures need to be planned ahead of time, giving time to seed alternative business activity. Success requires looking after the interests of workers, local communities as well as the energy industry, but not forgetting the interests of energy users and taxpayers.

Also: Investment in renewable energy technology will help Australia back onto its feet, shows report

“More coal plant closures will come, and probably sooner than many people think, as power prices have fallen and the competition from renewables is strong. Let’s be prepared for the change.”

Overcoming the ‘us and them’ mentality

Related research led by Dr Bec Colvin at ANU looks at the future of regional economies in coal areas as they transition away from coal, including in the Hunter Valley.

“These issues can be very contentious and even divisive. Everyday people need to be given the space to grapple with the complex social challenges of planning for a prosperous, low-emissions future,” Colvin says.

“This can mean governments and industry investing in genuinely participatory processes to make possible conversations across political and social divides, especially in regions that will experience the changes.

“A ‘just transition’ for regional communities requires overcoming the ‘us and them’ mentality promoted in the national political discourse.”

More Like This

Carbon emissions fell during COVID-19 – but it’s the shift away from coal that made the difference

Study confirms governments repeatedly ignored scientific advice when approving Adani coalmine

About the Author

ANU Newsroom
The latest and best news from the Australian National University

Published By

Featured Videos

Space technology predicts droughts several months in advance
ANU Science On Location: Booderee National Park
ANU Science On Location: Ningaloo Reef
A mix of science and sourdough
How does the crested pigeon make their mysterious alarm sound?
Why do magpies swoop?
Critically endangered swift parrot needs your help!
ANU Science On Location: Siding Spring Observatory
ANU Science On Location: Mountain Ash forests
ANU Science On Location: Warramunga Station
Secret life may thrive in warm caves under Antarctica’s glaciers
Scientists help solve mystery of what causes exploding stars
Case Closed: Mystery of How First Animals Appeared on Earth Has Been Solved
Palm cockatoos beat drum like Ringo Starr
Butterfly wings inspire new solar technologies
From window to mirror, on demand
The search for exploding stars
Coral bleaching on the Great Barrier Reef
Join The Search For Planet 9