Bees are good at maths, but bad at counting

  Last updated May 20, 2020 at 1:04 pm


Previous studies have found that bees can add, subtract, and understand zero – but the little geniuses can’t tell the difference between 4 or 5 flowers.

honeybees on dandelion

Why This Matters: Unbee-lievable.

If you were a honeybee, how would you choose where to find flowers? Imagine your first flight out of the hive searching for food. What would you do if you saw flower patches with one flower, or three, or twelve, or twenty?

Our new study, published in the Journal of Experimental Biology, tested honeybees on exactly this question. We wanted to understand how honeybees choose where to forage in environments like greenhouses where our food is pollinated, in local parks, or in our own backyards.

Specifically, our research looked at whether honeybees with no specific numerical training could choose a flower patch based on the quantity of flowers it had.

We found the bees could tell the difference between groups of 1 vs 4 flowers – but not between, say, 4 vs 5. Basically, they couldn’t differentiate between groups of 2 or more flowers.

Deeper: Honeybees can learn larger numbers – with a little bit of punishment

A mathematical matter of life and death

The ability to tell the difference between two quantities can mean life or death for an animal. “Quantity discrimination” can be vital for survival in tasks including:

  • resource comparison: choosing a larger quantity of food

  • aggressive interactions: choosing to avoid conflicts with larger groups of individuals, and

  • avoiding predators: choosing to stay with a larger group of animals of the same species to reduce your chance of being eaten.

We are gaining a better understanding of quantity discrimination across the animal kingdom. Primates and other mammals, amphibians, reptiles, birds and fish all display some form of quantity discrimination in day-to-day tasks. For example, fish use quantity discrimination to stay in larger groups to reduce the chance of being eaten by a predator.

Deeper: Honeybees can do maths

However, little is known about spontaneous number choices by insects.

How do bees choose where to forage?

Honeybees assess the available flowers based on several factors, including scent, colour, shape and size.

honeybee flowers

Which would you choose if you were a bee? Credit: Adrian Dyer/RMIT

Honeybees typically visit around 150 individual flowers per flight from the hive to collect resources such as nectar or pollen. For a honeybee, a high quantity of flowers in a single area would mean less energy exertion than having to fly to many flower patches with less flowers.

Using different numbers of artificial flowers, we wanted to test whether individual honeybees could discriminate between a range of quantities, and how they might determine the quality of a flower patch.

Our honeybees were shown pairs of flower quantities ranging from easier number comparisons (such as 1 flower vs 12 flowers) to more challenging scenarios (such as 4 flowers vs 5 flowers).

honeybee counting experiment

The experimental set-up (left) and the quantity comparisons (right). Honeybees succeeded at spontaneously discriminating between 1 vs 12, 1 vs 4, and 1 vs 3 flowers, but no other comparisons. The honeybees were trained to associate single yellow dots with sugar water before being shown quantity comparisons. Credit: Scarlett Howard

Interestingly, despite previous findings that trained honeybees can discriminate between challenging quantities and can also learn to add and subtract, the bees performed poorly in our spontaneous number task.

Deeper: Bees learn better when they can explore – humans might work the same way

We found they were only able to discriminate between 1 vs 3, 1 vs 4, and 1 vs 12 flowers – wherein they preferred the larger quantity. When 1 flower was an option they succeeded, but confused any comparisons between groups of 2 flowers or more.

This result suggests flower patch choice based on numerical-type cues is difficult for honeybees. And this has implications for how flower displays are interpreted.

With today being World Bee Day, why not take the opportunity to discover what bees are doing in gardens near you. Chances are they’re going to any flower patch with more than one flower, rather than paying much attention to absolute numbers.

This article was co-authored with Adrian Dyer from RMIT University.

This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.

More Like This

Aussie scientsts need your help keeping track of bees (please)

Honeybees get the concept of symbols as numbers

About the Author

Scarlett Howard
Dr Scarlett Howard is an Alfred Deakin Postdoctoral Research Fellow at Deakin University. Her research is primarily focussed around bee cognition and behaviour, as well as how increased urbanisation and anthropogenic changes affect Australian native bee species.

Published By

Deakin is a multi-award winning, internationally recognised university. More than 61,000 students study across our five campuses in Melbourne, Geelong and Warrnambool, and at the Cloud Campus and have chosen Deakin for its:

• excellent graduate outcomes

• practical, hands-on approach to learning

• access to state-of-the-art facilities

• teachers with experience and influence in their field

• courses that are informed by industry and offer real-world learning

• exceptional industry connections and work placement programs, in Australia and overseas

• flexible study options, whether on campus or online.


Featured Videos