‘Dr Google’ is almost always wrong

Proudly supported by

  Last updated May 18, 2020 at 2:40 pm


Turning to Google for a self-diagnosis may be doing more harm than good, with advice to seek medical attention only appropriate some of the time.


Step away from the keyboard, new research shows how inaccurate Dr Google can be. Credit: Burst/Unsplash

Why This Matters: While convenient, using Dr Google for a self-diagnosis is no replacement for a doctor.

Many people turn to ‘Dr Google’ for a self-diagnosis of their health symptoms and seek medical advice, but online symptom checkers are only accurate about a third of the time, according to new Edith Cowan University research.

The research, which is published in the Medical Journal of Australia, analysed 36 international mobile and web-based symptom checkers and found they produced the correct diagnosis as the first result just 36 per cent of the time, and within the top three results 52 per cent of the time.

The research also found that the advice provided on when and where to seek health care was accurate 49 per cent of the time.

It has been estimated that Google’s health related searches amount to approximately 70,000 every minute. Close to 40 per cent of Australians look for online health information for a self-diagnosis.

Also: If Googling your symptoms makes you sick with worry, there’s help

Lead author and ECU Masters student Michella Hill says the findings should give people pause for thought.

“While it may be tempting to use these tools to find out what may be causing your symptoms, most of the time they are unreliable at best and can be dangerous at worst,” she says.

Online symptom checkers ask users to list their symptoms before presenting possible diagnoses. Triage advice is about whether – or how quickly – the user should see a doctor or go to hospital.

The ‘cyberchondria’ effect

According to Hill, online symptom checkers may be providing a false sense of security.

“We’ve all been guilty of being ‘cyberchondriacs’ and googling at the first sign of a niggle or headache,” she says.

“But the reality is these websites and apps should be viewed very cautiously as they do not look at the whole picture – they don’t know your medical history or other symptoms.”

“For people who lack health knowledge, they may think the advice they’re given is accurate or that their condition is not serious when it may be.”

When to see a doctor

The research found that triage advice, that is when and where to seek healthcare, provided more accurate results than for diagnoses.

“We found the advice for seeking medical attention for emergency and urgent care cases was appropriate around 60 per cent of the time, but for non-emergencies that dropped to 30 to 40 per cent,” Hill says.

Also: Apps could soon predict your life expectancy, but do you want to know?

“Generally the triage advice erred on the side of caution, which in some ways is good but can lead to people going to an emergency department when they really don’t need to.”

A balance between self-diagnosis and going to the doctor

According to Hill, online symptom checkers can have a place in the modern health system.

“These sites are not a replacement for going to the doctor, but they can be useful in providing more information once you do have an official diagnosis,” she says.

“We’re also seeing symptom checkers being used to good effect with the current COVID-19 pandemic. For example, the UK’s National Health Service is using these tools to monitor symptoms and potential ‘hot spot’ locations for this disease on a national basis.”

Lack of quality control

Hill points to the lack of government regulation and data assurance as being major issues behind the quality of online symptom checkers.

“There is no real transparency or validation around how these sites are acquiring their data,” she said.

“We also found many of the international sites didn’t include some illnesses that exist in Australia, such as Ross River fever and Hendra virus, and they don’t list services relevant to Australia.”

More Like This

The problem in trying to regulate Facebook, Google and Amazon

Are we really ready to take advantage of AI in healthcare?

About the Author

ECU Newsroom
The latest and best news and perspectives from Edith Cowan University.

Published By

Featured Videos