No, an alcohol tax doesn’t only punish the poor

Proudly supported by

  Last updated December 11, 2019 at 4:13 pm

Topics:  

A new study debunks the myth that imposing an alcohol tax drives less-wealthy, heavy drinkers to drink even more.


Lineup of beer bottles alcohol tax




Why This Matters: Alcohol is one of the top reasons people seek medical treatment in Australia – and it’s completely preventable.




There is no evidence that a introducing a minimum unit price on alcohol as a deterrent against binge drinking would effectively make the poor poorer, finds a new study from UNSW.


Opponents of a minimum unit price (MUP), or a ‘floor price’ being imposed on alcohol – which would mandate all alcohol to be sold with a minimum price per standard drink –  have argued that not only would a minimum unit price have no effect on people’s drinking habits, but it would actually contribute to people drinking more out of despondency about their depleted disposable income.


But Anurag Sharma of UNSW’s School of Public and Community Medicine found that these arguments hold no water.


The effect of an alcohol tax is negligible


Using shop scanner data recording alcohol purchases made by 1400 Australian households over a 12-month period, Sharma and Monash University social scientist Brian Vandenberg estimated how an MUP of $2 per standard drink would affect the bank balances of consumers of alcohol, whether heavy drinkers, light or moderate.


As it turns out, the effect would be negligible.


“The idea behind the minimum unit price is to make alcohol more expensive for people who buy very cheap alcohol that is used to binge drink, like cask wine, which in Australia can cost as little as 30c a standard drink, making it much cheaper than bottled water,” Sharma says.


“So if this cost was increased to say $1.30, it’s a big jump in terms of percentage and if you are drinking it in large volumes, the financial burden is even bigger, which would lead to people reducing their consumption.”


Opponents of such a scheme – “mainly the alcohol industry”, says Sharma – argue that it puts more pressure on poorer people because the heavy drinkers that the pricing would likely affect tend to be from a lower social economic background.




Also: The alcohol industry is trying to convince us drinking is safer than it actually is




“So they are seeing this as another tax or another burden on the hip pocket of the poor, without any sufficient health benefits,” he says.


“What actually happens is there is a price effect of the so-called tax whereby when you increase the price, alcohol becomes more expensive and its consumption decreases.


“But opponents argue that an increased alcohol purchase bill resulting from introduction of floor price could have a negative effect on individual’s income – also called wealth effect – and they might start actually drinking more as alcohol consumption tends to increase during ‘hard times’. Our research shows that this wealth effect is negligible.”


A floor price has worked in the Northern Territory


The research, which is published in PLOS ONE, points to three different places in the world where an MUP or floor price has been introduced to discourage unhealthy drinking. The province of Saskatchewan in Canada, Scotland and recently the Northern Territory where the territory government introduced a floor of $1.30 a standard drink.


A report from the Northern Territory says hospitalisations for acute alcohol misuse in Alice Springs have dropped by 54% since October 2018 when the MUP was introduced.




Also: Drinking at levels deemed ‘safe’ could be killing you




“Minimum unit price is effective in reducing consumption of alcohol which is confirmed in Scotland, Canada and in the Northern Territory,” Sharma says.


“So we think this is an effective policy. The fact that it has been successfully implemented in the Northern Territory proves that it could work nationally, and there is a lot of research showing that reduction in alcohol consumption reduces domestic violence and violence on the streets, while there is also a link to cancer and quality of life.”


As to how well received an MUP would be in a nation that has a romantic vision of itself as being partial to a drink, Dr Sharma says the pricing would have little, if any, effect on the drinking patterns of light to moderate drinkers, while the savings in public health make it a no-brainer.


“Can you guess what is the top reason to seek medical treatment in Australia? It’s alcohol and cannabis use.


“Most of our scarce health resources are going toward treating people for conditions related to alcohol and drug abuse. That is the number one condition where the most of our resources and money goes to and that’s taxpayers’ money, and it is totally preventable.”


More Like This


The alcohol industry is trying to convince us drinking is safer than it actually is


Queensland’s alcohol laws increase preloading and fail to reduce violence




About the Author

UNSW Newsroom
The latest and best news from the University of New South Wales.

Published By

Featured Videos

Placeholder
Big Questions: Cancer
Placeholder
A future of nanobots in 180 seconds
Placeholder
Multi-user VR opens new worlds for medical research
Placeholder
Precision atom qubits achieve major quantum computing milestone
Placeholder
World's first complete design of a silicon quantum computer chip
Placeholder
Micro-factories - turning the world's waste burden into economic opportunities
Placeholder
Flip-flop qubits: a whole new quantum computing architecture
Placeholder
Ancient Babylonian tablet - world's first trig table
Placeholder
Life on Earth - and Mars?
Placeholder
“Desirable defects: Nano-scale structures of piezoelectrics” – Patrick Tung
Placeholder
Keeping Your Phone Safe from Hackers
Placeholder
Thru Fuze - a revolution in chronic back pain treatment (2015)
Placeholder
Breakthrough for stem cell therapies (2016)
Placeholder
The fortune contained in your mobile phone
Placeholder
Underwater With Emma Johnston
Placeholder
Flip-flop qubits: a whole new quantum computing architecture
Placeholder
The “Dressed Qubit” - breakthrough in quantum state stability (2016)
Placeholder
Pinpointing qubits in a silicon quantum computer (2016)
Placeholder
How to build a quantum computer in silicon (2015)
Placeholder
Quantum computer coding in silicon now possible (2015)
Placeholder
Crucial hurdle overcome for quantum computing (2015)
Placeholder
New world record for silicon quantum computing (2014)
Placeholder
Quantum data at the atom's heart (2013)
Placeholder
Towards a quantum internet (2013)
Placeholder
Single-atom transistor (2012)
Placeholder
Down to the Wire (2012)
Placeholder
Landmark in quantum computing (2012)
Placeholder
1. How Quantum Computers Will Change Our World
Placeholder
Quantum Computing Concepts – What will a quantum computer do?
Placeholder
Quantum Computing Concepts – Quantum Hardware
Placeholder
Quantum Computing Concepts – Quantum Algorithms
Placeholder
Quantum Computing Concepts – Quantum Logic
Placeholder
Quantum Computing Concepts – Entanglement
Placeholder
Quantum Computing Concepts - Quantum Measurement
Placeholder
Quantum Computing Concepts – Spin
Placeholder
Quantum Computing Concepts - Quantum Bits
Placeholder
Quantum Computing Concepts - Binary Logic
Placeholder
Rose Amal - Sustainable fuels from the Sun
Placeholder
Veena Sahajwalla - The E-Waste Alchemist
Placeholder
Katharina Gaus - Extreme Close-up on Immunity
Placeholder
In her element - Professor Emma Johnston
Placeholder
Martina Stenzel - Targeting Tumours with Tiny Assassins
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Why are we all athletes?
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Megafauna murder mystery
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Why are we so hairy?
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Why grannies matter
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Why do only humans experience puberty?
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Evolution of the backside
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Why we use symbols
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Evolutionary MasterChefs
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - The Paleo Diet fad
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Are races real?
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Are We Still Evolving?
Placeholder
How Did We Get Here? - Dangly Bits
Placeholder
Catastrophic Science: Climate Migrants
Placeholder
Catastrophic Science: De-Extinction
Placeholder
Catastrophic Science: Nuclear Disasters
Placeholder
Catastrophic Science: Storm Surges
Placeholder
Catastrophic Science: How the Japan tsunami changed science
Placeholder
Catastrophic Science: How the World Trade Centre collapsed
Placeholder
Catastrophic Science: Bushfires